Cabrera Silences Critics

Melky Cabrera did it again Thursday, another game, another game-winning hit. Clutch production silences carping critics. While some members of the Yankees' youth movement ride an endless wave of hype, Cabrera is thrown into the deep end of the pool . Sink or swim kid.

In 2006, an unknown Spanish speaking kid is called upon to fill the shoes of a hobbled, big-ticket free agent. Fresh legs, laser throws and a competent bat (.280/.360/.391) make the unceremonious debut a hit. Intangibles are icing on the cake, "Melky gives us energy."--(Torre)

In 2007, production settles closer to scouting reports, "Cabrera is a fourth outfielder."--(Infamous, anonymous scout.) 2008 starts with a new skipper whose stern demeanor is accentuated with a clenched jaw. Melky who, "Plays like he's in the park."--(Torre) whiffs. The Scranton shuttle delivers Cabrera back to the bushes.

2009 starts with the next big thing in center while Cabrera grabs some pine. Opportunity arrives, Melky delivers. Walk-off-wins pump up the team. First place fits.

Melky Cabrera isn't a star. The media doesn't fawn all over him. The organization doesn't invent mystery ailments to cover up lack of production. He is the best outfielder on a $200 million team. Not bad for a 24 year old who learned to swim in the deep end of the pool.

Photo/Boston.com