
Mike
Lupica writes for the
New York Daily News. His weekly column "
Shooting from the Lip" features Mike's opinions on a variety of subjects. I read the column because, growing up, I would read the
Daily News' Dick Young who featured a column of
similar style and content. The column would consistently rip my inept Yanks (the "Horace Clark era") it made me angry--but I would go out of my way to read it. Now a few decades later, hip deep in the tabloid era,
Lupica tries to recreate Young's methods.
Apparently, the formula works.
Lupica's column has been around for years and is published every Sunday. My perspective has changed. I used to give instant credibility to sportswriters. Unfortunately, a lot of material written or broadcast doesn't deserve credibility. Some of
Lupica's rants don't hold up to any type of prudent analysis. Here's one from this week:
"If the Yankees had lost Derek
Jeter at the end of August and the beginning of September the way the Red
Sox have lost Manny Ramirez with an oblique injury - and has there ever been a more fitting injury than that for Manny of Washington Heights? -
there'd be talk of Purple Hearts all around, right?"
Well actually, the correct response would be no. Comparing
Jeter to Manny is laughable. There is a reason the
Sox made
Varitek captain and put Ramirez on waivers. The Yankee captain's track record speaks for itself. Suggesting the Yank's
exaggerate injuries while the
Sox bravely carry on is not worthy of detailed comment. The problem
Lupica has is he has an agenda to fill. The Yank's are to be constantly criticized while the
Mets and Red
Sox complimented whenever possible.
Occasionally he'll write a misdirection but it all heads back to the same tired theme.
Last season we read, endlessly, that the Yank's bloated payroll, was the whole story while the
Mets were shrewdly building for the future. He actually wrote that Reyes/Wright were superior to A-Rod/
Jeter. Of course the facts are: A) the
Mets bought virtually every key component of their team (Reyes and Wright are the notable exception--2 excellent players developed through the farm system) B) The Yank's system produced a dynasty and recently has produced Wang,
Cano, Cabrera. Trying to maintain dominance while re-tooling is expensive. This season,
Lupica was on the
Sox bandwagon while the Yank's auditioned 8 rookie starting pitchers. The fact that the lead has shrunk from 14 1/2 games to 5 1/2 is excuse worthy--Manny missed a couple of weeks. His
replacement is hitting .400 but why
quibble.
There are countless examples of erroneous, pretzel-logic based commentary that show up on a weekly basis in Mike's column. I would urge any sports fan, with a sense of humor, to read it.